Should You “Gate” Your Case Studies?

BY Joel Klettke
April 3, 2016

Marketers have a tendency to get a little… overambitious.

These days, you have to look hard to find a website that doesn’t have some sort of pop-up or downloadable resource begging you to surrender your email.

For this post, we’re going to call that “Gating” – putting a gate in front of your content that someone has to deliberately go through.

Annoying as that might be, there’s a good reason marketers do that: it works.

Well, sometimes.

If the information on the other end is enticing and relevant enough and the source is trustworthy enough, then giving up your email might be a small enough price to pay.

It works best when the gated helps the lead do something they already want to do – whether that’s learning how to interview a customer or teaching them how to match their slacks with their socks.

With all the gating going on, a weird trend is starting to emerge: Gating case studies.

I’m seeing more and more marketers trying to use case studies as lead magnets to capture email.

Sometimes, case studies come with a teaser headline, like: “How We Grew Sales 200% for X Company”, with no further information unless a lead provides their email to download the study.

Other times, there’s a simple but complete one-pager case study that lays out the bare bones a lead might want to know (the problem, solution and results) but leaves the meaty details about the process behind a gate.

In either case, a lead needs to pony up their email if they want the whole story.

But is this a smart practice?

I’ll admit that this is something Case Study Buddy is eager to test with clients to see real-world results. I am very open to being wrong on this one.

But right now, I really don’t recommend it, and here’s why:

Consider the stage of the funnel a lead is likely to be at when they go out looking for case studies. Most likely, they’re in the awareness or evaluation stages.

  • In the “Awareness” stage, a lead has recognized they have a problem and is actively looking for a solution.
    They want to evaluate the efficacy of different approaches and companies, and read stories about people who have the same problems and found a solution.
  • In the “Evaluation” stage, a lead is establishing their preferences.
    They’re looking at both you AND your competitors. deciding on their priorities and seeing who’s the better fit.

In both of these stages, building credibility is crucial.

Case studies are HUGE credibility builders. When done right, they prove you can get results for people just like your leads. Not only that, but they reveal by way of example what a lead should expect when working with you.

I can think of no better asset to show a lead in the awareness and evaluation stages than a well-written, beautifully designed customer success story.

So why on earth would you hide all of that credibility-building power behind a gate that a lead will need to trust you to open?

Why make it harder for leads to see the incredible work you can do or hear from people like them why you’re the best company for the job?

If your competitor isn’t gating their case studies, I’d imagine they’re going to win that battle 9 times out of 10.

Instead, use your case studies to establish the trust that will make leads comfortable surrendering their email.

If someone reads  through a case study from start to finish, it’s a safe bet that they’re highly motivated to hear more from you at that point.

This is the perfect time to pitch other assets (gated or not) that add value or expand on the work you did for the client: Checklists for navigating their problem, comparison sheets, guides to convincing their stakeholders, ROI calculators and so on.

But if you ARE going to try gating your case studies, here’s what I recommend:

  • At very least, provide that quick one-pager so that a lead can get the gist of it.
  • Consider having at least a few completely accessible case studies that are gateways to your private ones.
  • Test it.

Have you succeeded with gated case studies? Am I full of bologna?

Drop me a line and tell me the story. Like I said, this one’s up for debate!

Ya, you like that? Well, there’s more where that came from!

A B2B Case Study Example: How Stripe Is Paying It Forward

A good B2B case study example isn’t always easy to find. So when I saw Stripe sharing their customer success stories online, I was impressed. I was immediately struck by how Stripe consistently positions their customers as the hero of their customer success stories. It’s a thread that runs through all—and every part of—their stories, from the challenges section of their written case studies to their video testimonials to their social media posts. Stripe also puts these success stories to work across their...

BY Holly Yoos

How We Helped Lever Create 22 Case Study Assets in 12 Months

In a highly competitive industry, Lever’s ATS and CRM platform was gaining ground. But in order to truly rise above the crowd, they needed to turn out strategic case studies at scale. With eager customers lining up to share their successes, the small customer marketing team only lacked the time to produce the stories effectively. With Case Study Buddy, Lever gained a partner with tactical expertise and an enterprise-friendly process that delivered: 🎯 22 targeted case study assets produced in...

BY Laurie Zottmann

What the Top 50 SaaS Companies Do With Their Case Studies (Free Report!)

Learn valuable lessons for creating your customer case studies and video testimonials at scale. If you’ve ever looked at your company’s case studies and wondered: How many customer success stories should you have? Should you prioritize written case studies over video testimonials? Or vice versa? How long should your written case studies be? How can you help prospects (and your sales team) find case studies that are most relevant to them? How should you lay out your written case studies...

BY Holly Yoos

Let’s tell your stories together.

Get in touch to start a conversation.

Contact Us

SaaS Industry Report


The State of SaaS Customer Success Stories in 2023

See what the top 50 SaaS companies are doing with their case studies and video testimonials. 

Get valuable takeaways you can use to level up your own marketing, applicable to any size or type of company. 

The State of SaaS Customer Success Stories 2023